Earls Collection Reviews

Earls Collection has an overall rating of 2.5 based on 22 reviews. Customer feedback on Earls Collection is mixed.

2.5/5.0

22 reviews

5 Stars

1

4 Stars

6

3 Stars

5

2 Stars

1

1 Star

9

All Earls Collection Reviews (22)
HeidiMartinez_58
June 02, 2026
"Didn’t feel authentic, and the reminders were too much"
The item just didn’t feel authentic to me. The packaging looked a little off, and once I noticed that, I lost trust in it. On top of that, the constant reminders felt way too aggressive, which made the whole experience even more frustrating
audreysarvis1154
May 24, 2026
"Looks just like the pictures"
It looks exactly like the photos, so no surprises there. I just wish it hadn’t felt like such a hassle to get everything set up, but once I did, it was pretty much spot on.
roy_Cranker99
May 21, 2026
"Good stock, just missed a few options"
I was in one of those slightly impatient moods where I just wanted to find what I needed and be done, so I checked earlscollection.com for a couple things I couldn’t track down elsewhere. To my surprise, they actually had most of it in stock, which felt like a small win.

A few sizes and colors were sold out, so I had to change my pick a little. It wasn’t the end of the world, but I did have that tiny disappointed moment because I was hoping the full range would be available.

Overall though, it was still a good experience. The stock info seemed clear, it saved me some time, and I left feeling satisfied even if I didn’t get my exact first choices.
CharleneLawson_06
May 02, 2026
"Packaging could’ve been better"
The box showed up a little dented, but luckily the item inside was totally fine. Compared to how most orders usually arrive these days, the packaging felt just kind of average. Not a big deal, but it definitely could’ve been packed a bit more securely.
charlesoakden4913
April 29, 2026
"Looks nice, but quality is just okay"
It looked nice when I first got it, but the material is kind of hard to describe, just a little thinner than I was expecting. It’s still totally usable and fair for the price, but I wouldn’t say the quality is amazing.
hello_jane691
April 08, 2026
"Checkout was a mess"
I tried grabbing a couple things from earlscollection.com, but the checkout was seriously frustrating 😕. After I entered my payment info, the page froze for a bit and then randomly sent me back to my cart like I hadn’t done anything. I had no idea if the order actually went through or not, so I ended up checking my bank just to be safe. Annoying for a first try, honestly, I just gave up and left the site.
catherine1993
April 06, 2026
"I mean, yeah, this was nice enough overall..."
I mean, yeah, this was nice enough overall. The stuff was good and the prices felt fair to me, like... for what I got, I can’t really complain.
HeatherDelgado_55
April 05, 2026
"Prices weren’t clear"
I thought I was paying one price, but then extra fees popped up later. It just wasn’t clear, like, not clear at all, and that was frustrating...
CRICHTON
March 24, 2026
"Support never got back to me"
I tried contacting support twice and never heard a thing back, which feels like they just didn’t care enough to respond. Frustrating experience, and I don’t think I’ll bother ordering from here again.
Alonzo.watring
March 20, 2026
"Earls Collection has a clean, modern look, that’s..."
Earls Collection has a clean, modern look, that’s always a good start. It’s easy to browse, things aren’t cluttered, and the overall layout makes sense without trying too hard.
That said, it does feel a bit basic in a few spots. Some of the images and sections could use more detail, because obviously people want a better feel for what they’re looking at before getting interested. It’s not a bad site at all, just didn’t really stand out to me
Robert-land
March 15, 2026
"Decent overall, but the shipping was annoying"
The product was fine and I don’t really have any major complaints, but the delivery took longer than I expected. Not a huge deal, just kind of annoying waiting around for it.
hello_daren979
February 16, 2026
"I tried wearing it for a bit..."
I tried wearing it for a bit, but the material felt really itchy against my skin. From what I remember, it just wasn’t comfortable at all, so I wouldn’t reach for it again.
COOK
February 02, 2026
"Overall, I’m happy with it"
In the end, I’d say it was pretty much as described. The item matched the listing overall, though the sizing felt a little off for me.
hello_wilfred180
January 15, 2026
"Sizing didn’t match the guide"
I ordered my usual size from earlscollection.com, but the fit was way different than what the size chart made it seem like. It was tight in some areas and strangely loose in others, so it just felt off overall. I really wish the sizing instructions were clearer because I was expecting the chart to be more accurate. Now I have to deal with a return, which is frustrating.
WILLIS
January 12, 2026
"Website was kinda frustrating"
I did like some of the stuff I saw, but using the site was annoying honestly. Pages were loading slow and the filters didn’t really work right on my phone. Took me way too long just to find basic things.
EsperanzaWhitley_70
January 04, 2026
"NA"
NA
jennaknisley6570
January 04, 2026
"I was just trying to swap for..."
I was just trying to swap for a different size, but the replies have been really slow and the return instructions weren’t very clear. Maybe I missed something somewhere, but it’s still not sorted out and it’s been more hassle than expected. I don’t think I’ll be ordering again.
todd1993
January 03, 2026
"Refund came faster than I thought"
I had to cancel my order and I was a little worried about getting my money back. The refund ended up showing in my account quicker than I expected though. Support got back to me the next day and explained what was happening. It wasnt totally perfect since I had to reach out first, but in the end it was fine. Id give it 4 stars.
rita_Bryson72
December 24, 2025
"I feel dumb for even trusting their payment page"
The payment page just didn’t feel safe to me at all. I started putting in my card info and immediately got a bad feeling. i feel kind of stupid for trusting them enough to even get that far.
CAMPBELL
December 20, 2025
"Tracking was mostly solid"
Tracking worked well overall, like I could still follow where things were going and wasn’t totally in the dark, but the updates did show up a little late sometimes, so I’d check and think nothing changed and then suddenly there’d be a new update from earlier. Not a huge deal, just slightly annoying

View More Reviews

Have a question about Earls Collection?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.